Lemon leaf

California Lemon Law Myths and Facts

Lemons Are for Eating, Not Driving.

There is a lot of conflicting information about the California Lemon Law. You may have heard that your vehicle needs a certain number of repairs, that only brand-new cars can ever qualify, or that a recall automatically makes a vehicle a lemon. The reality is more nuanced.

California Lemon Lawyers, APC, focuses exclusively on California Lemon Law and vehicle warranty matters. From our office in Sherman Oaks, CA, we help consumers throughout California understand how the law may apply to their individual circumstances.

Car engine overheating with hood open and steam billowing out

Myth: Your Vehicle Has to Be Completely Unusable

Fact: A vehicle does not necessarily have to stop running completely for a potential Lemon Law claim to exist.

California law considers whether a qualifying nonconformity substantially impairs the vehicle's use, value, or safety, along with other circumstances.

Recurring engine, transmission, electrical, braking, steering, or other significant problems may deserve further evaluation even when the vehicle remains driveable.

Mechanic under a car inspecting the underside with tools, wearing orange gloves in a garage

Myth: Four Repair Attempts Automatically Make a Vehicle a Lemon

Fact: Four repair attempts can be important, but they do not automatically guarantee a refund or replacement.

California's Lemon Law contains a rebuttable presumption concerning a reasonable number of repair attempts under specified circumstances. Other factors can also affect a claim.

Your complete repair history should be reviewed rather than relying on a single number.

Dark vintage sedan parked outdoors in a wet driveway, front view.

Myth: Every Used Car Is Covered by the Lemon Law

Fact: Used-vehicle cases can be different from new-vehicle cases.

California's enhanced Lemon Law remedies apply specifically to qualifying new motor vehicles, while other warranty protections may apply to used vehicles sold with written warranties.

The vehicle's warranty, purchase circumstances, and repair history are important when determining what legal protections may be available.

Mechanic writing on a clipboard beside an open car engine outdoors

Myth: A Recall Automatically Makes Your Car a Lemon

Fact: A recall by itself does not automatically establish a Lemon Law claim.

A recall means the manufacturer has identified a safety or compliance issue requiring a remedy. Whether you may have a Lemon Law or warranty claim depends on additional circumstances, including the defect, warranty coverage, and repair history.

Car key handed over at a desk with contract papers, calculator, and toy car, suggesting a car sale or rental

Myth: You Can't Have a Claim If You Lease Your Vehicle

Fact: Leased vehicles can be covered by California's Lemon Law under qualifying circumstances.

The California Lemon Law recognizes certain leased new motor vehicles within its definition of a new motor vehicle.

If you lease a vehicle experiencing ongoing warranty problems, don't assume that leasing automatically eliminates your rights.

Woman crouching beside a black car, inspecting the front wheel while talking on a phone.

Myth: You Need to Figure Everything Out Before Calling an Attorney

Fact: That's what a case evaluation is for.

You don't need to know whether your vehicle legally qualifies before contacting California Lemon Lawyers, APC. Providing your vehicle information, warranty details, repair history, and supporting documents can help the firm evaluate your circumstances.

Keep copies of your:

  • Purchase or lease agreement
  • Current registration
  • Dealer repair orders
  • Maintenance records
  • Warranty documents
  • Manufacturer communications
Lemon leaf

California Lemon Law Myths FAQs

  • Is There a Specific Number of Repairs Required?

    Not for every case. California law addresses a reasonable number of repair opportunities, and certain statutory presumptions may apply in qualifying circumstances. Your individual facts matter.

  • Can I Have a Lemon Law Claim If My Vehicle Still Runs?

    Possibly. A vehicle can remain operational while experiencing a defect that substantially affects its use, value, or safety.

  • Does a Manufacturer Have to Give Me a Refund Automatically?

    Not necessarily. The manufacturer may have obligations under California law when statutory requirements are met, but whether those requirements apply depends on the circumstances of the vehicle and claim.

  • How Can I Find Out If My Vehicle Qualifies?

    Call 818-960-1945 or complete the online qualification form for a free case evaluation with California Lemon Lawyers, APC.

Loading reviews...

Lemon leaf

Get the Facts About Your Vehicle

Don't rely on rumors or assumptions about California Lemon Law. California Lemon Lawyers, APC, can review your situation and help you understand your potential options.

Our firm has handled hundreds of cases and recovered more than $10 million in verdicts and settlements. There are no attorney fees unless you win, subject to the terms of your representation.

California Lemon Lawyers, APC

15250 Ventura Blvd., Suite 1220

Sherman Oaks, CA 91403

Phone: 818-960-1945

Email: nicka@calemonlawinfo.com

Serving: All of California

The information on this website is provided for general informational purposes only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.